Illegal fishing remains a significant challenge to the sustainable management of Indonesia's marine fisheries, particularly within the 12-nautical-mile provincial waters, where fisheries surveillance involves multiple institutions operating under a decentralized governance framework. This study aims to estimate direct production-related economic losses from illegal fishing and to develop an integrated, multi-level fisheries surveillance model for Indonesia's provincial waters. The study was conducted in four provinces within Fisheries Management Area (WPPNRI) 712: Banten, West Java, Central Java, and East Java—using a mixed-methods approach combining fishing-production analysis, field observations, structured and in-depth interviews, legal and institutional analysis, comparative gap analysis, and process mapping. Direct production-related economic losses were estimated using seasonal fishing-production data and government-established fish reference prices. The results identified the continued use of prohibited fishing gears, particularly arad in Serang, Cirebon, and Rembang, and cantrang in Lamongan. The aggregate direct production-related economic losses associated with these prohibited fishing practices were estimated at approximately USD 1.61 million in Serang, in Cirebon, USD 55.62 million in Rembang, and USD 15.87 million in Lamongan. These estimates represent the monetary value of fisheries production associated with the prohibited fishing practices examined and should not be interpreted as a comprehensive valuation of the broader ecological, social, or long-term economic impacts of illegal fishing. Based on the institutional analysis, this study proposes an integrated multi-level fisheries surveillance model comprising four interrelated components: (1) community-based monitoring and reporting involving fishers and community surveillance groups; (2) coordinated multi-agency surveillance involving provincial and national institutions according to their respective mandates; (3) structured reporting and institutional coordination; and (4) inter-regional cooperation across provincial jurisdictions. The proposed model integrates community-level monitoring with provincial and national surveillance functions to strengthen information flows, institutional coordination, and cross-jurisdictional cooperation. As the model represents a proposed institutional framework rather than an empirically validated intervention, further stakeholder validation, pilot implementation, and empirical evaluation are required to assess its operational feasibility and effectiveness.