Small pelagic fisheries are vital to the economic resilience of coastal communities in archipelagic regions, yet they face distinctive challenges associated with isolation and logistical constraints. This study analyzes price volatility, supply chain structure, and marketing efficiency of small pelagic fish (Decapterus macarellus, Selaroides leptolepis, and Euthynnus affinis) on Biaro Island, Siau Tagulandang Biaro (SITARO) Regency, Indonesia. Using a mixed-methods approach, data were collected through "grand tour" observations and interviews with 30 purposively selected fishermen and 8 traders identified through snowball sampling. Descriptive qualitative analysis was used to map the supply chains, while quantitative analysis was used to calculate farmer’s share, marketing margins, and revenue-cost (R/C) ratios. The results reveal a complex, multi-tiered supply chain involving fishermen, collectors, intermediaries, and industrial consumers, which increases distribution costs and weakens fishermen's bargaining position. The findings indicate substantial price volatility driven by seasonality, weather conditions, and industrial demand. Although the average Farmer’s Share of 74.5% indicates that fishermen receive a relatively high proportion of the final consumer price and an R/C ratio >1 indicates profitable marketing activities, disparities in profit distribution persist, with intermediaries capturing higher margins than primary producers. These findings show that high marketing efficiency does not necessarily translate into economic equity for island-based fishermen and indicate the need for policy interventions to shorten supply chains and improve market access in remote island settings.